Such figures can be particularly helpful to nonspecialist readers of cell, molecular and structural biology papers. How long should I wait for a response from the journal? Authors subsequently receive an e-proof, including the figures, and can also download a PDF proof of the layout. So in conclusion, yes, editors can add reviews but should do so with extreme caution and rarity. Editors, on the other hand, must guard against a different category of mistake, as it is their responsibility to balance the intense investment of the authors in a particular decision against the more diffuse interests not only of their readers but also of other authors. LetPub Scientific Journal Selector (2018-2021), Nature Energy published in 2016, UNITED STATES. In light of such uncertainty, the threshold for reversing a decision must be set well above the level of 'noise' in the process: otherwise, decisions would simply go back and forth endlessly in a kind of Brownian motion. Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more. Once the decision has been made to peer-review the paper, the choice of referees is made by the editor who has been assigned the manuscript, who will be handling other papers in the same field, in consultation with editors handling submissions in related fields when necessary. good . A reject decision at this stage is final and cannot be reversed. What could this mean? To obtain Before publication, the Journals and Editorial press office also informs the press / public information officers of authors' institutions to allow them to prepare their own publicity. Nat Neurosci 5, 917 (2002). Peer review comments, cover letter and more. on 05 Apr, 2021. Confirm that you would also like to sign up for free personalized email coaching for this stage. If the editor has invited the authors to resubmit, authors must ensure that all the referees technical comments have been satisfactorily addressed (not just some of them), unless specifically advised otherwise by the editor in the letter, and must accompany the resubmitted version with a point-by-point response to the referees comments. The paper is accepted for publication in principle once the authors have made some revisions in response to the referees comments. What does it mean if the status is 'under consideration' for two weeks? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. A final decision of acceptance or rejection of the revised manuscript is made by the editors as soon as they conclude that they have sufficient information at hand for doing so. How do I write an inquiry to the editor about my manuscript's current status? Editor Decision When making a decision, we expect that the academic editor checks the following: The suitability of selected reviewers; Adequacy of reviewer comments and author response; Overall scientific quality of the paper. At each stage, the editor will discuss the manuscript with editorial colleagues in the light of referees reports, and send a letter to the author offering one of the following options: Editors letters also contain detailed guidance about the papers format and style where appropriate (see below), which should be read in conjunction with the manuscript formatting guide when revising and resubmitting. The peer review file is published online as a supplementary peer review file. Authors are usually informed within a week if the paper is not being considered. It doesnt mean anything other than the editor has started to look at your paper. Yes, its appropriate. How did it go for you after this? if you strongly disagree with the editorial decision, you can appeal against it unless the editor has clearly specified otherwise. We oversee this process to ensure that your manuscript contains everything our editors and peer reviewers need to perform a fair and thorough assessment of your work. Wishing you the best of luck on your paper. 9.3 weeks. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn1002-917. Editors reject manuscripts at this stage for one or more technical reasons: The manuscript is missing essential elements or sections required by the journal. PRX editors make every effort to arrive at a clear decision on the disposition of a manuscript within a reasonable time. Deciding when or whether you should write a rebuttal, determining what steps you should take next if you choose the . Most referees honour their prior agreement with Nature to deliver a report within seven days or other agreed time limit, and send their reports online. Confirm that you would also like to sign up for free personalized email coaching for this stage. We understand your anxiety :-) However, the decision on manuscript acceptance depends on several factors, such as availability and responsiveness of peer reviewers and the extent of revisions recommended. It means the editor has actually received it and is reviewing. How to write an email to the editor inquiring about the current status of my paper? Special attention is paid by the editors to the readability of submitted material. [CDATA[// >